Paper · S1287
Unidentified aerial phenomena I. Observations of events
Zhilyaev and colleagues report daytime imaging, angular motion and brightness variation. Their dark-object distances depend on assumed albedo and atmospheric scattering; derived sizes and extreme speeds inherit those assumptions. Moon and water-tower comparisons offer limited calibration checks. A separate two-station claim depends on synchronization and matching the same object. These reported measurements do not establish craft identity or extraterrestrial origin.
Read the paper at arxiv.orgWhat we checked
Earlier accepted review covers all168 supplied HTML lines and captions. A specialist separately inspected eight whole received v1 PDF layouts,23 numbered figures, four equations and two terminal references; no HTML/text credit is repeated. Root reviewed the whole analytical packet and exact pins, without root primary reading. Native stamp is August23,2022; server modification January2023 and differing ETag/received hash remain separate. This is the identified report family; the exact version Loeb read is unknown.
Supplied v1 text and eight native layouts reviewed; raw observations unresolved
How we check sources
Not checked yet
- Dark-object distances assume albedo, Rayleigh scattering and a homogeneous atmosphere; sizes/speeds inherit these assumptions. Moon/tower comparisons are author-reported calibration checks. Matching two stations depends on timestamps, geometry and same-object association. Raw recordings, original images, atmospheric measurements, calibration and code were not reviewed or reproduced. Extreme estimates do not establish craft or extraterrestrial identity.
- Figures6/14 show RGB profiles without wavelength axes, rather than independently resolved spectroscopy. Figure4 lacks a physical speed unit; figure16 Time has no stated axis unit despite20ms caption sampling. Figure22 panels show differing windows/scales. Text25Hz versus abstract/conclusion10–20Hz remains literal. Fine ticks/values were not exhaustively transcribed into a dataset.
- Equation1 prints a second term(V−B)J while adjacent prose uses(V−R)J. Citation[x] remains unresolved. No silent repair or numerical reproduction. All23 figures were viewed; one same-page glyph reinspection adds no ninth layout. V2, final-journal copy, original authentication and the two cited books/papers remain unreviewed.
- Observatory/NASUkraine affiliation and descriptions of public NASA studies do not prove joint government tasking or an approach to Loeb. The paper does not authenticate his separate visiting-official account. Later S1288/S1289/S7514 reports reuse the programme and are dependent, rather than additional independent confirmation; Loeb commentary critiques these shared claims.
Cite this record
B.E. Zhilyaev, V.N. Petukhov, V.M. Reshetnyk. Unidentified aerial phenomena I. Observations of events. August 23, 2022. BioParity S1287. https://bioparity.io/sources/S1287Record data (JSON)